Is there any surer sign of fall than apple butter? Our first batch of 2024 is on the shelves today! Featuring early season apples from Christ Orchard in Elwood, Illinois, this batch has uniquely bright fresh apple flavor with a little tang from apple cider vinegar and a little depth of flavor from our house-made vanilla extract, cinnamon and nutmeg. Per customer request, we made both 6 oz. and pint sizes this year so you can indulge a little or a lot!